High School Students Humiliated at Rally for Not Graduating

bakersfield rallyBAKERSFIELD, Calif. (FOX News Channel) – More than 30 high school seniors were called by name to leave an assembly in front of their peers, because they were not eligible to graduate. Now, the school in Bakersfield, Calif., is apologizing to each of them and their parents for the incident, which some have called “humiliating.”

“I’m going to make you stop and I’m going to make you look back at this group in front of you, because it might be the last group event with this graduating class,” one of North High School’s two truancy officers said during the assembly before calling forward 34 seniors in front of 350 others.

“We have six weeks of school left, we’re not done yet,” the truancy officer, who was not identified by name, continued. “And it’s not only for seniors but everybody else involved. We need to get to graduation safely, quickly and with as much fun possible, but we are not done yet.”

The man went on to say that when he called each students’ name, he wanted them to stop and look at their peers.

“As you walk away, keep looking and keep in mind what you’re sacrificing,” he said, encouraging those not yet eligible to graduate to complete whatever they needed to in order to receive their diploma. “This is your opportunity to get this work done.”

Though the speech was meant to motivate students, John Teves, spokesman for the school district, said the truancy officer’s decision to name the students publicly was a “very poor choice.” He explained that students ineligible to graduate are usually separated into a separate assembly where they learn what they need to complete.

“They humiliated them,” said Dylan Newsome, a senior who told the Bakersfield Californian six of the students named completed their requirements the same day of the assembly. “I don’t think it was right for them to do it right in front of everybody.”

“I was at the rally, we were all having a good time until they blacklisted the students who are not graduating,” Shea Holtachulte, whose brother’s name was called, told KERO. “For another thing, administrators don’t know what personal issues students are going through this semester, so humiliating them is completely unfair.”

Calling the incident a “breach of sensitivity,” Teves told the Bakersfield Californian that the district is now considering staff sensitivity training. It has not been decided if any disciplinary action will be taken against the two truancy officers involved.

KERO reported that the student who filmed the public naming on a cellphone said some teachers thought it was inappropriate as well and apologized to students afterward.

4 comments

  • Tia

    Ouch ~ potentially life-long damage done to those little souls. School as we know it is not for everyone. Look at our biggest contributors in such areas as science and music (think Einstein, Mozart)…high school seems very small indeed, but not as small as those truancy officers' minds.

  • Barb

    This is what happens when students use media to spread and exaggerate. I have personal experience with this school district. I taught there for 6 years and I can guarantee you, these students KNEW this was going to happen. They have been told since Freshman what was going to be expected to graduate. They also had a similar experience in middle school. As far as the student talking about special needs students. Yes, some of them could be special needs, but as a special education teacher in this district, I know for a fact that they were given accommodations galore. It all comes down to, you can't MAKE the student do their work, or to learn no matter how much you work with them. This district is notorious for non-parental support, so that doesn't make things any easier. The way it happened, happens all the time there. It's nothing new. I have no sympathy, not even as a teacher because it is the most frustrating thing to watch a student just let it go, no matter how much you offer to help in ALL ways.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s