Police: Telling If a Gun Is Real Or Fake Sometimes “Virtually Impossible”

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

PAW PAW, Mich. – Is the gun real or fake? It’s a distinction police officers make in the line of duty and a decision that comes with real consequences.

On Saturday afternoon in Battle Creek, police said an officer shot a person who was carrying what appeared to be a handgun, police tell FOX 17 the person shot was a 14-year-old carrying a fake weapon.

While that incident is being investigated by Michigan State Police, Lt. Chuck Christensen showed us a side-by-side comparison of real and fake guns to illustrate how difficult it can be to tell the difference between the two guns.

Christensen said the encounters with fake guns are rare, but when they happen he said they can have life changing consequences.

“In a situation, an emotionally charged situation like that, there are many things going through your mind,” the Lt. said.  “You have seconds to react.  When you do react, as a human being you want to make sure you made the right call.”

Lt. Christensen said throughout an officers training they are taught to shoot if they feel a life is in danger, “If the conditions are low-light and you have seconds to react, it’s virtually impossible to tell the difference between a legitimate firearm and a b b gun or an Airsoft weapon.”

A call made even more difficult with imitation guns made to look identical to the real thing.  Police said the most common copy-cat gun they encounter is an Airsoft gun.

“It’s a gun that fires a plastic b b, usually a 20 millimeter b b,” said Lt. Christensen.  “A lot of kids have these and they can fully automatic, semi-automatic, some run on a propane and they use them to play Airsoft wars.”

The fakes are usually distinguished by having an orange tip, something police say can be easily modified with a piece of tape.

14-year-old Nick King was said by Battle Creek Police to have been carrying a replica of a Smith and Wesson semi-automatic handgun when he was shot by a 21-year veteran of the Battle Creek Police Department.

He continues to recover in a hospital, his mother tells FOX 17 that she has hired a lawyer to represent the family going forward.  The police officer was put on leave while MSP continues its investigation.

FOX 17 spoke with Dr. David Carter, a former police officer and current professor of criminal justice at Michigan State University.  He said he’s interviewed 25 officers involved in a shooting with a person carrying a fake gun for a study commissioned by the U.S. Department of Justice.

He concluded in all cases the officers focused on the persons behavior, rather than type of gun in their hands.

“The officer is focused on the face, because the face and the eyes gives you insight on what this person is thinking and doing,” said Dr. Carter.  “They are not looking at the gun and at the hands, their peripheral vision will pick it up, but that is not what they are focusing on.”

Neither the professor nor Lt. Christensen said they believe officer training will change.  Lt. Christensen said he does encourage people who own imitation guns to be cautious.

“Set the gun down on the ground immediately if you even see a police car coming because it’s very hard for the officer out of the street to know the difference,” he said.

Dr. Carter said in most of the cases he studied, the police officer was responding to a 9-1-1 call of a person armed with a gun.  He said that information will put the officer in a mindset that the situation his entering is one of potential danger.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


  • ivan

    Focus on the eyes not the weapon huh. Well his eyes said he was going to shoot at me. How dumb. Focus on the weapon if it never gets pointed in the cops direction or at someone else there is no reason to fire. The current story says he was carrying the weapon, not that he pointed it at anyone or even used it to commit a crime. I understand why the news never reports the story as it really happened and always make the shooting seem justified. Cant have the public get whipped up into a frenzy by getting the true account of a cop just chomping at the bit to shoot a kid.

  • Captain_Obvious

    I saw a video toady on the news depicting this scenario and it’s funny how experts were not interviewed in the matter. Apparently the police can’t find someone to back them when they make mistake as there were a few mistakes made on BOTH sides that could of resulted in the two officers shooting kids with fake guns. First off, they’re kids so a police officer pointing real guns and yelling at them when they are probably scared in the first place is going to make them do some things that may seem like they they’re a threat out of shock because they probably don’t want to get shot. Second, this officer approached these kids out in the open leaving his only response to someone popping out of hiding as a threat that would need to be shot. Now why wouldn’t you take cover or try to protect yourself to avoid the situation getting out of control or making the mistake of shooting someone that is not a lethal threat? Let’s go find a few doctor’s who deal with psychology and then lets bring in a few people that know something about approaching a suspect with a weapon and see what they have to say. Police don’t deal with these situations on a regular basis and in this video alone I saw officers putting themselves in a situation because either because the officer lacked common sense or had no idea how to handle the situation. I also saw kids in a situation with guns pulled on them being threatened to be shot. You can’t blame the kids alone when the adults involved are just as responsible and walk around letting people know they are more responsible than the public and trained for these situations when they are apparently not.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.