Storms moving in Tuesday evening

Family feels scammed by landlord and left without power for days

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

scammed rentalGRAND RAPIDS, Mich. – A Grand Rapids family signed a one-year lease for an apartment after they responded to a Craigslist ad that seemed too good to be true; it turned out it was.

Dan Nelson and his family were without power four days since Monday, during this hot and muggy weather. They live at 2017 Eastern SE, a rental owned by Evergreen Properties. On Tuesday FOX 17 called Nelson’s landlord, Steve Benner, who said power should have been restored by Wednesday.

Nelson and his family have lived here for about a month, but he told FOX 17 they are for a new home, as they stay in hotels hoping their power gets turned back on.

Nelson’s young daughter clung to his leg and told him, “but I’m not going to a different hotel again!”

Nelson said he pays their rent and utilities on time and directly to Evergreen Properties; but their power was cut off on Monday. As of Thursday morning, only one light bulb was turned on.

“At the moment, yep, that’s all we’ve got turned on,” said Nelson. “We were hoping that maybe the kitchen, or where the fridge is, or where the washer is would be on, but no. We don’t have anything right now; just a light bulb.”

Then the meter Nelson believes powers the rest of his unit is gone; he said a technical support employee with Consumers Energy removed it on Tuesday.

“So my meter is this one that’s all the way on the end that is missing,” said Nelson, as he showed FOX 17 this missing, mislabeled meter. “It’s labeled second floor, 2021, but as it turns out it’s our meter and it’s missing.”

According to Nelson, his family lost more than $1,000 in spoiled groceries and hotel stays. For four days, he could not get any straight answers: Nelson said he tried calling his landlord dozens of times and got no answer; then he called Consumers Energy, and since only his landlord is on the account, he got no explanation.

“I would tell (my landlord) if I could get ahold of him, that would be great,” said Nelson. “Yeah we’re definitely planning on leaving. There’s no way I would stay here. Talking with the other tenants, this happens often; Consumers (Energy) admits that this happens often. I can’t fathom staying here paying for utilities that may or may not be on, and may or may not be going to Consumers (Energy), I’ve got to leave.”

FOX 17 went and looked for answers. When we spoke with Evergreen Properties, Benner was not available. One employee called Consumers Energy then said she was “not sure” why the power was shut off. She also told FOX 17 that the missing meter is being replaced with a Smart Meter.

According to the Better Business Bureau, Evergreen Properties has a “D” rating. On the BBB’s website, Evergreen Properties has two closed complaints, including one complaint that Evergreen Properties never responded to the BBB about.

Nelson said he found this unit initially on Craigslist and would like his family’s experience to serve as a warning for other renters.

“The Craigslist ad was written very unprofessionally,” explained Nelson. “Trying to get ahold of him just to get the place was difficult. I had to search around on Google just to get the guy’s number; I just wanted to see if it was legit.”

Nelson said he only signed a preliminary lease with Evergreen Properties, and is now in touch with one employee there.

Nelson reached out to FOX 17 and said as of Thursday evening his power was restored. He said he will be meeting with Evergreen Properties on Friday and will ask to for a reimbursement for his expenses.

Nelson said he hopes to move his family within a month.

To help avoid any scams before signing a future lease, check out any potential rental companies with the Better Business Bureau, and search for online reviews of that company.

If you feel you have been scammed get in touch with your local Better Business Bureau and file a complaint. See the BBB’s website or call their West Michigan office at (616) 774-8236.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


  • Robin Alberts

    Never rent or work for Steve Benner or anyone associated with him or Evergreen Properties. He is a scammer, thief and will rip you off!!!!

  • amy

    Yes a big theif and scam artist. I worked for him and I know how he works. He will sound sweet but sell you a dream. I’m looking at time and charges for him being a scam artist. This happens to all renters…….stay away

  • Bee-ware

    When are people ever going to learn that “Craigslist” is dangerous!
    People have been robbed, scammed, Beaten and even murdered through contacts made on that site! It is bad news and it is more often than not that only BAD things come from dealings done there!
    Be cognizant, Alert and know the old saying, “if it sounds too good to be true, It usually is!”
    I hope these folks find a good place to call home and deal with honest individuals- I also hope bad karma exists and targets the S.O.B who pulled this stunt with an innocent family!
    To this Bennet: What a Sorry piece of trash you are!

  • Taylor Vann

    It’s so true, I’m a commercial business tenant of Mr. Benner. I own many businesses around the state, and I have never met a better candidate for “American Greed.” It is sincerely appalling. Without posting our full story, The Office of The United States Trustee thought that my information was very interesting in regards to bankruptcy fraud.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.