Excessive Heat Warning Issued for West Michigan

Consumers Energy gets $515K fine, but what does that mean for customers?

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

LANSING, Mich.— Consumers Energy will pay $515,8000 for violating estimating billing practices.

More than 12,000 customers have struggled to pay unthinkable bills because of estimated reads. Some of those bills were tens of thousands of dollars.

Fox 17 Problem Solver, Cassandra Arsenault, has been covering this story for almost a year with customers having issues with estimated billing breaking the news last summer. Several customers who have dealt with paying for these huge bills in the past say the Consumers Energy fine to the state doesn’t help their situation.

Consumers Energy claims they are doing everything they can to make it right with their customers. They are installing smart meters, and have raised their actual read rate. They will be under the close eye of Michigan Public Service Commission for the next three years. However, a customer who had to pay a hefty estimated bill price for their family budget said his trust in the company is lost for now.

“I’m glad they are getting fined. I don’t know what it does for any of their customers though,” said Jody Hill.

Hill is a Kalamazoo resident, and a father of three. He got an estimated bill of over $1,000 for just one month, more than five times higher than his usual $150 dollar bill. His bills are combined electric and gas.

He has since paid it off after some billing confusion between him and Consumers Energy, but when it happened it really put his family in a bad spot.

“It absolutely ruined 3 months of my life basically. That’s how much that money cost me. It put three months of my life on hold,” said Hill.

Hill made huge sacrifices to keep his power on and said he was never able to connect  with a real person  instead lost in a maze of automated answering systems.

“I had to skip a mortgage payment which costs me a little bit of extra money. We’ve been eating food out of the freezer instead of fresh food,” said Hill.

When Hill heard the Michigan Public Service Commission was fining Consumers over billing violations, he hoped for relief.

“It all goes to the state. It’s not something that goes to customers and so that money goes into the general fund,” said Judy Palnau, the spokeswoman for the Michigan Public Service Commission.

The commission said customers like Hill should have and will be able to pay back their large bills in payments matching the number of months they were estimated, so if they were estimated for 16 months they will have 16 months to pay it back.

Consumers Energy told us that all situations will be handled on a case by case basis, and there will be no mass compensation.

The good news is that anyone who has Consumers Energy as their electric and gas provider: the company cannot pass the cost of the fines onto customers.

“In the past perhaps that was spread among all other customers so there will be a very close eye watching for that and making sure customers don’t pay for that,” said Palnau.

For customers like Hill who were slapped with unexpected large bill, trust is something you can’t buy with money.

“I don’t really trust them at all. I don’t have an option. I can’t change electric carriers. You can’t go to somebody else and say I’d like to buy electricity from you. You are forced to buy it.”

Consumers has installed 1 million smart meters, and plans to install a million more this year. They have improved their actual read rate by 97 percent.

The commission said they have also implemented the same restrictions for gas reading regulations as for electric so this doesn’t happen to gas customers.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


  • Natilee Belanger

    The state of Michigan need to get their act together. We paid our income tax . It was 1500. Our credit union sent the money to state of Michigan. They got paid. They cashed the check. They turned around
    at least three times saying we didn’t pay. It was on my husbands credit we didn’t pay. This year again were told didn’t pay. Took my Michigan refund from taxes. Then said still owe $31. Husband had paid his income tax. Again saying not paid. This time tax lady has it. Haven’t heard from her. So don’t know if this one is straightened up. Somebody that works in the tax department does not have it together. How many other people are having problems with the State of Michigan?

  • Brandon

    They are turning off my power over an error on theyre part. Nonpast due bills etc! Wont even try to help us! They have a monopoly and bully customers because the state allows it!

  • evelyn delbridge

    Ive had some terrible bills from consumers, i called an electrician to my house an he said theres no reason my bills should be as high as they are. When i called consumers they had me read my meter again an charged me 500 more dollars on my bill. So what can you do? How do you fight a company that does this an gets away with it.?

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.