Winter Weather Advisory for Friday Night and Saturday

Over a dozen residents homeless after pastor failed to pay utilities

MUSKEGON HEIGHTS, Mich. -- Around 15 people are homeless just days before Christmas after the landlord, James Duncan Jr., failed to pay the utility bills. The building was condemned Wednesday night by the city, and Muskegon Heights officials said the problems have been mounting for over a year.

Some of the residents reached out to FOX 17 via Facebook and said their food, clothing and Christmas presents are still in the home. However, they are unable to access them. The city told FOX 17 the property owner can physically grant them access during daylight hours, but he has yet to do so.

Resident Tamela Day said, "Let us know we finna [sic] get evicted. Let us know. You takin' our money every week. So why can't we have running water, hot water at that, lights and whatever?"

She said she's faithfully paid her rent to Duncan for the past couple of months. Day and her kids are now out on the street as of Wednesday night. The city evicted residents and told them to leave within four hours.

City officials said because there are no working utilities the home is unlivable. Officials also mandated no trespassing which means tenants cannot get access to their belongings that were left behind.

Resident Latresha Dixon said, "It’s people that went Christmas shopping for food and clothes and toys. We left a whole bunch of food. We just spent $300 on grocery shopping."

"We still wearing clothes from a couple days ago. We can’t get nothing. No clothes, no food, no socks, nothing, and it’s crazy," Dixon explained.

Muskegon Heights fire chief Christopher Dean said, "It’s a horrible time of year and horrible situation for people to be in when they have no place to go because they’ve been placed in a substandard housing unit.”

Dean said a complaint from Health and Human Services about utilities that had been shutoff prompted the city to take action.

According to officials, Duncan is behind on his water and sewer bill by $3,000. With no electricity, Dean said residents resorted to putting themselves in danger by using candles for light. That's a fire hazard. He said some kept the stove on for heat which would raise the carbon dioxide levels in the home. (Yes, dioxide.)

Dean said, “We have been working diligently on and off with Pastor Duncan for over a year. Unfortunately, as we continue to work with him on this the conditions of the structure continue to deteriorate.”

James Duncan is the pastor of The Revival Miracle Temple just four minutes down the road from the property.

Chief Dean said the city filed a complaint in circuit court against the pastor and his wife, Pamela, due to the level of deterioration and the number of times police have been called to the building.

The dilapidated building in question is considered an illegal rental. According to court records, Duncan and his wife failed to register it as a rental with the city and used it to operate the Muskegon Adult Foster Care Home. The state revoked the foster care license in March 2016.

Dean said, "We gave specific instructions to the pastor that when it's daylight, when people can safely see, to get these people back in to get their stuff, get their other items so that they can move forward."

As police guarded the property against trespassers, FOX 17 approached a city inspector who reiterated that residents can only get inside if the pastor is present during daylight hours.

The pastor, who lives in a nearly 9,000 square foot waterfront home in North Muskegon, was outside the church when FOX 17 drove up. Pastor Duncan and a group of people saw our crew and retreated inside. One man blocked the door from outside.

We asked for the man to let the pastor know we wanted to speak with him. The man replied, "As you can see. He was… he seen ya’ll. So."

An unidentified woman came back outside. FOX 17 informed her the people need the pastor in order to access their belongings.

She said, "This just happened last night. People have lives. Things happen."

FOX 17 informed her the incident happened Wednesday night and not Thursday night as she incorrectly stated in her defense of the pastor. The man nor woman had an answer for his delay in getting the residents access to the building. The conversation went the same direction many of the residents have to go, and that's nowhere.

"It's like 14 other residents from 11 months [old] to like 60 year old mens and womens [sic] that live here," Day said.

"And still, no answer," she said.

FOX 17 attempted to contact Mr. Duncan multiple times prior to the newscast but have yet to hear back from him for his side of the story.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

9 comments

  • BOB

    Appears the pastors was there and maybe would have let people in until FOX17 news crew showed up. Could those people get their things out if FOX17 wasn’t there??

  • Baditude

    The pastor should have paid the bills and kept the place livible along with properly registered with the county. If he can afford a 9,000 square foot house, but not cover his obligations to those who helped him be able to achieve it, he should not only be ashamed of himself but he should be busting his butt to fix the problem and compensate the tennents for the poor conditions. The pastor could have opened the church as a place for those affected to stay while he s straightening out the mess. Finally he should be preparing for it to be very hot when he moves on from this Earth as I have a feeling being a slum loard will put him in the express elevator going down.

  • cannonproductionsco

    I bet the money spent to “guard” the place from rightful tenants would have more than paid to turn the lights back on. Ridiculous, Muskegon. Candles are a fire hazard? Being kicked out in freezing cold temperatures and prevented from accessing your food and clothing is LIFE hazard.
    So stupid. Why do we need government again? To protect people from themselves? No, thank you.

    • Michael

      Once a residence has the utilities shut off it is no longer fit for occupancy.

      I pay my utility bills. I don’t pay tax to pay yours too.

  • Mika

    Well I think this ppl should pay more for rent not just 35 a month.. I no a person that lives there and he letting them pay for less . So is not those ppl fault. It’s his.. stop giving and stop helping ppl that on drugs.

  • Kathryn Riggs

    Really, as always more victim shaming! This minister, supposedly a man of God, would allow this to happen? All while he is warm and cozy in North Muskegon, no if he was paying the necessary bills, had the necessary permits, etc, this would not have happened.