High School Football Scoreboard

Attorneys explain lawsuit filed against Rogers Plaza

WYOMING, Mich. — Attorneys representing the family of Claire Dykstra, a 2-year-old girl who has a disability, say Rogers Plaza discriminated against Claire when employees asked her to leave the mall at the end of 2018.

Claire used to go to Rogers Plaza regularly with her physical therapist to use her walker. The lawsuit claims this action violates Claire’s rights under federal and state statues.

“So what this lawsuit alleges, is that the actions taken by the mall, which was to tell her she couldn’t sit down, that she’s really not allowed to do her physical therapy there, violated the statute,” said Scott Noto, the attorney representing Claire’s parents.

She is just learning to walk because she has a rare brain disorder that interrupts the communication from the left side to the right side of her brain, which affects her motor skills.

The lawsuit alleges Claire should be able to walk in the mall, just as any other person who would go to the mall to walk for exercise.

“That’s why we have laws like this. That’s why the (Americans with Disabilities Act) was passed in 1990,” said attorney Theodore Westbrook, who is representing Claire’s parents.

Claire’s parent’s attorneys also want to make something clear: there is no payday in sight for the Dykstra family. Saying, that’s simply not an option for ADA lawsuits in terms of settlement.

“Plaintiffs cannot get money damages. It’s just not available to them. Any idea that the family is looking for a payday out of this, it’s just not true,” Westbrook said.

Rather, this family is filing the lawsuit because of the principle of the thing.

“Hopefully, one benefit of a lawsuit of this nature, it encourages people to address these types of things. It also gives businesses an idea of what’s proper under federal and state laws, and that’s important,” Noto said.

Attorneys representing Rogers Plaza did not respond to FOX 17’s request for comment regarding the pending lawsuit.

Previously, attorney Jason Chozick, who represents the mall’s owners, told FOX 17 children sitting on the floor pose as a safety risk and that the mall is not the place to conduct physical therapy.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


  • Larry Green

    I totally agree with the lawsuit Each time I go to Rogers plaza I see the walkabouts, that is people using the mall as a place to do their phisical theory and exercise. I don’t see the mall asking them to leave so what’s the difference? Perhaps only the disibillty itself If that’s the case then I would tend to think this is a ADA violation and needs correcting. I gathered from the article and other information that she was sitting on the floor, this is also typical as I’m sure what have all in our lives at some point had to reroute our steps arround children sitting on the floor. I don’t believe this constitutes a public safety issie as the malls attorney (s) have claimed . Beware though this would set a presedence and clear the way for this this at all malls and beyond to have these sometimes annoying walkabouts at all malls. The increase of issues and liabilities will increase burden an the malls and insurance resulting in increases cost to customers. End result down the line high prices at the malls leading to eventually closing the malls. Remember the good old drive in movies? Mostly gone due to insurance company cost due to liability and ability to profit with such charges. Bottom line customers will pay for the benefit of the walkabouts.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.