Dog owners concerned herbicides in water made pets sick

ALLEGAN COUNTY, Mich. -- Pet owners at Dumont Lake Campground believe herbicides sprayed into the water have sickened their dogs. The company that sprayed the herbicides said there's no correlation.

Michelle Goodell, a seasonal camper said, "We maybe thought it was heat exhaustion, but he's still not normal."

She said her dog, Toby, has been lethargic for weeks. Goodell said it's one of the milder symptoms dogs are experiencing after playing in the water.

Paul Lapinne said his two dogs are also ill. He's among the residents reporting hives and diarrhea.

Campground manager Chris Bertram said, "Monday, they had sprayed."

Bertram, who said medical bills are mounting for his German Shepard, said he spotted a man in a hazmat suit spraying something into Dumont Lake on Monday. He learned this is the company's second visit this year.

June 4 was the first visit. A man was spraying herbicides to treat algae and weeds.

Lapinne said, "Nobody knew. It's a surprise to us."

The company doing the spraying, PLM Lake and Land management, told FOX 17 that seven property owners on the lake paid for the treatment.

Jason Broekstra, the company's vice president of Great Lakes operations, said the company obtained a permit from EGLE (formerly DEQ).

"There's no impact. There's no swimming restrictions associated with these products on their labels. Everything is approved by EPA. Everything is approved by the Department of (Agriculture). Everything is approved by EGLE, formerly known as the DEQ," he explained.

Broekstra said notices were posted within the less than two acre area sprayed and 100 feet outside of that zone. He said when areas less than two acres are sprayed, notices are not required to be posted outside of the 100-foot zone.

He explained that the notices that were posted give a 24-hour water-use restriction so that people are not in the worker's way, and so the products can settle on the invasive plants.

"If there were going to be any adverse effects to wildlife, ya know, raccoons, dogs, deer (or) little children are not going to read signs. There's no way, no how we could ever use these products in our lakes, and we'd be having issues that you're referring to everywhere," Broekstra said.

He said this type of work takes place on lakes around Michigan all summer. Broekstra encourages people to get their pets to the veterinarian which these owners have done, but he said it's simply not the herbicides causing their issues.

Lapinne said, "We're hoping that our dogs get better because they're like family to us."

In response to FOX 17, the Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy (EGLE) released the following:

EGLE has received several reports concerning sick dogs (including one canine death) in the vicinity of Dumont Lake Campground.  The campground is located on Dumont Lake, a 210-acre waterbody in Allegan County, north of the city of Allegan.  EGLE has also received reports of two dead turtles, a dead racoon, and approximately 20 dead birds at Dumont Lake. 

EGLE is currently gathering information regarding the chemical treatment of the lake.  Based on the information that EGLE has been able to gather to date, shoreline treatments of aquatic plants and algae occurred on 0.86 acres on the northwest end of the lake, and 0.46 acres on the northeast end.  The treatments occurred on June 4, 2019, and July 8, 2019.  The chemical treatments occurred along the shoreline of seven properties, and included the use of copper sulfate, flumioxazin, and diquat dibromide under an Aquatic Nuisance Control (ANC) permit issued by EGLE.  The WRD is continuing to actively investigate the reports concerning human and dog illness. 

Regarding your question concerning proper notifications, EGLE is currently conducting a routine compliance check on the ANC permit that was issued to PLM Lake and Land Management.  The Aquatic Nuisance Control statute and permit require that the treatment area be posted with signs every 100 feet before treatment.  Properties adjacent to the treatment area must be posted also.  If the treatment area is less than 2 acres (as in the case of the Dumont Lake treatment), the public access and public and private parks that are not adjacent to treated properties do not have to be posted on the day of treatment.

EGLE has also been in touch with the Department of Agriculture and Rural Development and the Department of Health and Human Services regarding the reports of human and dog illnesses.  These agencies are completing separate evaluations to determine possible causes of the human and dog illnesses.  The local health department has also been contacted to determine if any human illnesses have been reported from the area.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


  • Jenny

    What isn’t in this story is what happens AFTER plants are poisoned. First the poisoned plants start to decompose. Every little thing that LIVES on and off the plants, dies and starts to decompose. All that sudden decomposition uses oxygen so oxygen levels plummet. More stuff starts to die off. Muscles, snails, tadpoles, baby fish (all of which might actually EAT the invasive plants, wiped out.) Now if this continues, oxygen levels get low enough so the aerobic bacteria that is blooming to eat all that decomposing material can no longer survive, anaerobic bacteria can set up. Blue green algae, which is not an algae at all but cyanobacteria which lives in low oxygen levels. Now THAT STUFF is nasty and can make anything sick. I would not be one bit surprised that the lake in question has some of that in it.

    GOD people STOP USING POISON on stuff. Nature does not like imbalances. If you left the snails, muscles, tadpoles, many tiny aquatic insects, all EAT PLANTS. If their food source booms, leave it alone and in the next few years the populations of eaters of those plants will increase. Without using poisons.

  • Chet Steadman

    There is sooooo much runoff from local fields due to the heavy rains this year. We went to Dumont in June and the water was the nastiest I have ever seen. It was brown. I doubt any of this was from spraying weeds. Lakes across the state spray for weeds.

  • David Ruhle

    We have two dogs that got sick and one has died. We feel that it was from a run off of herbicide from two fields that drain into a ditch that goes through our property

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.